Woman relaxing at home, drinking coffee and using smartphone to contact her PBM.

Table of Contents

H2 headings will appear here...

SUCCESS STATS

PBM 101

How to Compare PBMs on Member Satisfaction

How to Compare PBMs on Member Satisfaction

Portrait of SmithRx

SmithRx

Key Takeaways

  • Member satisfaction with the pharmacy benefit shapes employee experience and how many questions reach HR.

  • Member-level evidence has to come from each PBM, so ask for the method and service metrics behind any score given during RFP.

  • Compare member and client satisfaction scores separately, checking the survey date, population, and benchmark.

When it’s time to renew your pharmacy benefits partnership or issue a request for proposal (RFP), cost is often at the center of the conversation. But the pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) you choose also shapes how employees experience their benefits, from filling a prescription to getting an answer when they need help.

Members form their impressions at the pharmacy counter, during support calls, and when their pharmacy benefit plan requires approval for a medication. Clear communication and accessible support can help them navigate those moments with confidence. When questions go unanswered, employees may turn to HR for help.

Comparing that experience across PBMs takes more than reviewing a satisfaction score. Employers need to ask finalists for member-level evidence, understand how each measure was collected, and review the service data behind it. Evaluated alongside price and clinical performance, member experience can become a clear, defensible part of the selection process.

Is There a Ranking of PBMs by Member Satisfaction?

There is no single, widely-used ranking of PBMs by member satisfaction. The closest thing to a standard is URAC's PBM accreditation, which requires accredited PBMs to report audited call center measures each year. URAC's PBM performance report published in January 2026 presents those results only in aggregated, de-identified form.

One widely referenced source is the yearly PBM Customer Satisfaction Report from pharmacy benefits consulting firm Pharmaceutical Strategies Group (PSG). It surveyed 250 benefits leaders from employers, health plans, hospital and health systems, and unions about their PBMs. The public findings describe plan sponsor sentiment across these groups; results for individual PBMs are available in a fee-based supplement.

Medicare Star Ratings, which CMS publishes for Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans, do not cover employer-sponsored plans. Pharmacy ratings and PBM market-share rankings can provide other perspectives, but they don’t tell you how members rate their PBM experience.

If a finalist claims to deliver a strong member experience, ask for the survey results and service data behind that claim during your RFP.

Where Members Experience Their Pharmacy Benefit

Member satisfaction forms at a handful of predictable touchpoints. Each one can resolve a member's question easily or escalate to HR, which is why member satisfaction belongs in a PBM evaluation.

These are the touchpoints worth probing with every finalist:

  • Utilization management communication, including how members hear about prior authorization status when their pharmacy benefit plan requires it.

  • Access to knowledgeable support, including channels, hours, and who answers the phone.

  • Benefit changes and transitions, including how members are notified before go-live and how ongoing prescriptions continue.

  • Self-service information, including plan details, prescription history, and pricing lookup available without a phone call.

Prior authorization (PA), a utilization management tool, deserves specific attention because it is the point where coverage criteria meet a member who is waiting on a medication. The criteria, review roles, and communication steps for PA vary by PBM and plan design.

When members get a clear answer at each touchpoint, fewer questions need to route through the benefits team. When they cannot, a pharmacy question can become HR's work.

How to Measure Member Satisfaction in a PBM Evaluation

Touchpoints become comparable when each finalist answers the same written requests during the RFP or renewal. Use the checklist below as a starting point; it sets no numeric targets, since appropriate thresholds depend on your unique population, goals, and plan design.

Area

What to Request

What It Tells You

Accreditation and audited measures

Whether the PBM holds URAC PBM accreditation, its accreditation dates, and whether it will share the call center results it reports to URAC

Whether service figures follow audited, standardized definitions you can compare across finalists

Member satisfaction

Score, scale, survey population, timing, response method, and benchmark source

Whether the score describes members like yours and can be compared across finalists

Member effort

How the PBM measures ease of getting help, reported separately from satisfaction

Whether members can complete a task without repeated contacts

Support access

Average speed to answer, abandonment rate, channels, and hours

How reachable support is when members need it

Resolution

First-contact resolution, escalation rates, and complaint trends by category

Which situations need follow-up and where HR may hear about them

Utilization management communication

How members are notified of prior authorization status, with standard and urgent turnaround reported separately

How clearly members learn about coverage decisions and how long each type of review takes

Transition support

Member notification plan, handling of ongoing prescriptions and existing prior authorizations, files requested from the outgoing PBM, and the plan if files are incomplete

What continuity members can expect at go-live, given the files available

Ongoing reporting

Which member service metrics appear in regular reports and how often

Whether you can monitor the experience after the contract starts

URAC’s PBM performance report, published in January 2026, provides an aggregate reference point for call center measures among accredited PBMs. Results are de-identified, so employers should ask finalists to share their own figures for comparison.

Ask finalists for sample reports, then confirm that member service metrics in your PBM reporting match what they presented during the RFP.

How to Interpret a PBM's Satisfaction Claims

Satisfaction figures in finalist presentations are rarely comparable as presented. One PBM may cite a member survey, another a client survey, and a third an app-store rating, each with a different scale and year.

Before scoring any figure, confirm these details:

  • Who was surveyed, since member satisfaction and client satisfaction measure different audiences.

  • When the survey ran, since an undated score cannot be compared with a dated one.

  • Which benchmark the PBM cites, and whether its own measure uses the same definition and population.

  • Whether a figure is an average, since an average wait time is not a guarantee for every call.

  • Whether results come from an internal survey or a third-party review platform.

A finalist that answers these points in writing gives you evidence you can defend to leadership and document in your fiduciary process. A truly transparent PBM should be as open about how it measures service as it is about how it gets paid.

How SmithRx Approaches Member Satisfaction

Benefits teams want members supported without HR becoming the escalation desk for pharmacy questions. Our member support is 100% in-house and on-shore, so the people members reach know the benefit we administer.

The SmithRx Member Portal and Mobile App let members see plan details, prescriptions, prior authorization updates, and savings alerts. When a member wants a person, support is available through web chat, email, and phone.

Alongside that support, SmithRx's Drug Pathways Engine evaluates claims for clinically appropriate lower-net-cost options. Some opportunities are applied automatically, while others involve a supported next step, with guidance from our teams when action is needed.

On member satisfaction, SmithRx members rated their experience 4.5 out of 5 in 2025, against a 4.2 benchmark. Employers can hold that figure to the same checklist we recommend for every finalist: who was surveyed, when, and against which benchmark. We also hold URAC Accreditation for Pharmacy Benefit Management.

Member satisfaction becomes comparable when every PBM answers the same questions with the same evidence. Make it a scored category in your next renewal or RFP, and ask each finalist how it measures the experience your employees will have.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do non-Big 3 PBMs have more satisfied customers than the Big 3?

In PSG's 2026 survey, benefits leaders using non-Big 3 PBMs continued to report higher satisfaction in general, though their scores declined in specific areas. The respondents are plan sponsors, so the survey offers no member-level comparison between the two groups.

Can member satisfaction be written into a PBM contract?

Employers can negotiate member service commitments when the contract defines each metric, how it is measured, and how often it is reported. Ask each finalist which member experience measures it will report against and what happens if a target is missed.

Can switching PBMs disrupt the member experience?

A switch changes core member-facing details, including ID cards and the carryover of ongoing prescriptions and existing prior authorizations. Continuity depends on the transition plan and on which files are available, so plan the member side of a PBM transition well before go-live.

How often should employers review member experience data?

Review it on a set cadence, such as quarterly business reviews, and again after any plan design or formulary change that affects members. A review after a change shows whether members were notified clearly and where new questions are surfacing.

Ask AI about this article

Portrait of SmithRx
SmithRx

SmithRx is the #1 Modern PBM, relentlessly focused on eliminating the conflicts and complexity of legacy pharmacy benefits. Built on radical transparency and fiduciary alignment, we empower employers to take control of their pharmacy spend and experience with our 100% pass-through model.

PBM 101

What Is a Fiduciary-Aligned PBM? A Guide for Employer Plan Sponsors

“Fiduciary-aligned” is in almost every PBM proposal. Here’s how plan sponsors can test the claim.

date

PBM 101

What Is a Fiduciary-Aligned PBM? A Guide for Employer Plan Sponsors

“Fiduciary-aligned” is in almost every PBM proposal. Here’s how plan sponsors can test the claim.

date

Gear Icon Centered Among Sequential Circular Steps.

PBM 101

How Does a Modern PBM Work?

Every PBM in your RFP may call itself transparent or pass-through. Here's how to test a modern PBM's contract, data access, and clinical execution before you sign.

date

Gear Icon Centered Among Sequential Circular Steps.

PBM 101

How Does a Modern PBM Work? A Guide for Benefits Leaders

Every PBM in your RFP may call itself transparent or pass-through. Here's how to test a modern PBM's contract, data access, and clinical execution before you sign.

date

Gear Icon Centered Among Sequential Circular Steps.

PBM 101

How Does a Modern PBM Work? A Guide for Benefits Leaders

Every PBM in your RFP may call itself transparent or pass-through. Here's how to test a modern PBM's contract, data access, and clinical execution before you sign.

date

Origami progression from crumpled paper to boat, swan, and a red bird taking flight

PBM 101

Modern PBM vs. Traditional PBM: 6 Ways the PBM Model Has Evolved

Discover six crucial areas where modern PBMs are redefining the industry, offering insights into how these innovations are creating more transparent, efficient, and client-focused pharmacy benefit solutions.

date

Origami progression from crumpled paper to boat, swan, and a red bird taking flight

PBM 101

Modern PBM vs. Traditional PBM: 6 Ways the PBM Model Has Evolved

Discover six crucial areas where modern PBMs are redefining the industry, offering insights into how these innovations are creating more transparent, efficient, and client-focused pharmacy benefit solutions.

date